Okay this is a little funny. I was just lurking at the wiki (I violated the mantra, I know) and there's a thread about "who's changed their mind about the finale?" The consensus now seems to be that the finale sucked since it ended up being a series finale. No shit. I was amused by that. Okay, but seriously, go read k8ie's post at SCS in the BTR thread. You'll feel better.
I did read it. I really loved the idea. Then it kinda made me sad, cos it meant that somewhere along the way Sarah either died or failed miserably.
My only problem - playing Devil's advocate - with the theory is that I wonder if Sarah is really so sure of her ability to change everything. So absolutely sure that she would allow John to jump into the future because she's absolutely convinced that she will manage to stop JD. I know Sarah's all for the mission, and she is utterly determined. But the path to JD seems to roll inexorably along no matter what they do and that fact must play at the back of her mind - "aside from the fact the world's about to end..."
Things are closing in, time is running out, everyone she trusts is gone, and she may or may not be sick. Her odds right there and then aren't good. I love that she doesn't falter in her single-mindedness to change John's fate, but I'm not totally convinced that she's convinced she will ultimately succeed. Not enough to allow John that jump without putting up a fight.
Having said that... I do love K8ie's theory: Sarah's right there, with the choice in front of her and no time for her to think it through or second guess herself. Go John, I'll stop it. Wherever you end up, I will have stopped it. You'll be safe.
It's so simple and so lovely and so very Sarah.
How strange would it have been had John jumped forward into a utopia?! "Hey, mom did a damn good job!"
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
ninetydegrees
no subject
on 2009-05-21 04:47 pm (UTC)no subject
on 2009-05-21 09:13 pm (UTC)My only problem - playing Devil's advocate - with the theory is that I wonder if Sarah is really so sure of her ability to change everything. So absolutely sure that she would allow John to jump into the future because she's absolutely convinced that she will manage to stop JD. I know Sarah's all for the mission, and she is utterly determined. But the path to JD seems to roll inexorably along no matter what they do and that fact must play at the back of her mind - "aside from the fact the world's about to end..."
Things are closing in, time is running out, everyone she trusts is gone, and she may or may not be sick. Her odds right there and then aren't good. I love that she doesn't falter in her single-mindedness to change John's fate, but I'm not totally convinced that she's convinced she will ultimately succeed. Not enough to allow John that jump without putting up a fight.
Having said that... I do love K8ie's theory: Sarah's right there, with the choice in front of her and no time for her to think it through or second guess herself. Go John, I'll stop it. Wherever you end up, I will have stopped it. You'll be safe.
It's so simple and so lovely and so very Sarah.
How strange would it have been had John jumped forward into a utopia?! "Hey, mom did a damn good job!"